The commodification of innocence

The commodification of innocence: How capitalism fuels the sexualization of young girls

The innocence of childhood, a time for exploration, play, and the unburdened development of self, is increasingly under siege, particularly for young girls. From the moment they're born, girls in Western societies are often bombarded with messages that prioritize their appearance and define their worth by how desirable they are to others. They are relentlessly targeted and objectified by a system that prioritizes profit over the well-being of children. The sexualization of young girls has become a pervasive and deeply troubling issue in Western societies, fueled by a capitalist machine that thrives on objectification and the commodification of the female body.

This disturbing trend is deeply ingrained in the fabric of Western culture, manifesting in various forms, from the clothes girls wear to the toys they play with, the media they consume, and their interactions on social media platforms. The insidious nature of this phenomenon lies in its ability to subtly influence young girls' perceptions of themselves, their inherent worth, and their place in the world.

In their book So Sexy So Soon, authors Diane Levin and Jean Kilbourne share numerous stories from parents and educators highlighting how children from preschool to their tween years (ages 8-12) are grappling with sexualized messages, often struggling to cope. The authors attribute much of the responsibility to the American commercial culture, which has increasingly utilized sexuality and violence in marketing toys, clothing, music, and entertainment to young children over the past few decades.

Fashioning Lolitas: The sexualization of children's clothing

One of the most blatant examples of the sexualization of young girls is evident in the realm of children's fashion. A casual stroll through virtually any clothing store in the West reveals a stark contrast between the girls' and boys' sections. While boys' clothing is typically practical and geared towards play, girls' clothing is often designed to mimic adult styles, frequently featuring revealing cuts, tight fits, and suggestive slogans.

Crop tops for pre-teens, dresses with plunging necklines marketed to young girls, and the ubiquitous presence of high heels and makeup in advertising campaigns aimed at increasingly younger demographics are not accidental trends. They represent a calculated marketing strategy that capitalizes on the idea of "mini-me" fashion, blurring the lines between childhood and adulthood. This push for premature sexualization contributes to a culture where girls are seen as objects of desire rather than children.

The toy industry’s role in the sexualization of young girls

The toy industry also plays a significant role in the sexualization of young girls. While toys should ideally encourage imagination, creativity, and learning, many toys marketed to girls focus on beauty and fashion.

Dolls like Bratz and certain iterations of Barbie, with their exaggerated features and emphasis on appearance, promote an unrealistic and often hyper-sexualized image of femininity. These dolls frequently come with accessories like makeup kits and high heels, further emphasizing the importance of physical appearance.

The message conveyed is clear: girls should prioritize being pretty and desirable above all else in order to capture the attention of the opposite gender. This can lead to body image issues, low self-esteem, and a focus on external validation from the early years of a girl’s life. Studies have shown a correlation between playing with hyper-sexualized dolls and negative body image in young girls, as they become preoccupied with their looks and internalize the male gaze at a very young age.

From fairytales to femme fatales: Sexualization in children's literature and media

Even seemingly innocent children's books and movies can contribute to the sexualization of young girls. While classic fairy tales often feature damsels in distress awaiting rescue by a prince, modern adaptations sometimes amplify these themes, focusing on the princess's beauty and emphasizing her role as a romantic interest.

Sophisticated marketing techniques are used to target young girls with sexualized imagery and messages. This can include ads on websites and social media platforms they frequent, as well as product placement in shows and movies they watch.

The message, though subtle, is powerful: a girl's worth is tied to her beauty and her ability to attract male attention. This shifts the focus from a child's natural play and development to their attractiveness to others, particularly the male gaze.

Losing childhood: Premature exposure and its consequences

One of the most tragic consequences of the sexualization of young girls is the loss of childhood. They are pushed to grow up too quickly and pressured to adopt adult behaviors and appearances before they are emotionally ready. This premature exposure to sexualized messages and imagery can rob them of their innocence and disrupt their healthy development. They may experience anxiety, feelings of shame, depression, and even trauma. The pressure to be "sexy" or "desirable" can create a sense of unease and excessive, precocious self-consciousness, making it difficult for them to simply enjoy being children.

Capitalism and patriarchy: A toxic alliance

The sexualization of young girls is inextricably linked to the Western capitalist system, which thrives on the objectification and commodification of the female body. In a capitalist society, capital is prioritized over humanity, and individuals are valued based on their ability to generate and accumulate capital. This system, according to Imam Khamenei, uses various means to convince women that it is to their benefit to make themselves more sexually attractive for men on the streets.

It perpetuates a patriarchal view, where the male gender is considered superior to the female gender. Women are often reduced to their physical attributes and their value is linked to their sexual attractiveness to men.

Capitalism's relentless pursuit of profit drives industries to exploit the vulnerability of young girls, using them as tools to sell products and services. The fashion, toy, and media industries all contribute to the sexualization of young girls, perpetuating harmful stereotypes and objectifying their bodies.

Imam Khamenei, in a meeting with hundreds of prominent women on July 2012, pointed out this patriarchal view within the Western culture, calling them out for their true incentive for constantly raising the issue of women’s rights, saying, “The cornerstone of Western culture is that women should be socially presented as a product, an object that men can benefit from.”

Western capitalism perpetuates the very practices it wrongly attributes to Islam. In capitalism, capital reigns supreme, and humanity is merely a tool to serve its accumulation. The Western commercialization of childhood contributes to a culture where girls are seen as commodities, their worth measured by their ability to attract attention and generate revenue. The constant barrage of sexualized messages and images creates a demand for more and more of the same, perpetuating a vicious cycle that is harmful to young girls.

While it is essential to dismantle the capitalist machine that profits from objectifying young girls, we must also be mindful of the potential pitfalls of certain strains of feminist ideology. Some feminist perspectives, in their pursuit of eliminating perceived gender stereotypes, have arguably contributed to the very confusion they seek to resolve, by attacking the essence of humanity and undermining the inherent characteristics of women.

Although these movements seemingly seek to provide liberation from traditional gender roles, some approaches advocate for the erasure of inherent gender differences, potentially leading to confusion among children about their identity. This has coincided with a notable increase in the number of young people identifying as part of the LGBTQ+ community, with recent surveys indicating that 30% of Gen Z adults in the US identify as such[1]. Additionally, the continuous exposure of children in the US to these deviant thoughts has contributed to a surge in diagnoses of gender dysphoria. Many young individuals now believe they are transgender and are increasingly seeking medical interventions[2].

Furthermore, the very system that fuels the sexualization of young girls also profits from the fallout. Major pharmaceutical companies and Western capitalism reap significant gains from the mental health struggles that result from this premature exposure. The early onset of puberty[3], increasingly prevalent due to the pervasive nature of sexual content in Western countries, adds another layer of complexity. The same forces that exploit young girls' bodies for profit also capitalize on the psychological and physical consequences.

Navigating this landscape requires a critical approach – one that not only challenges harmful capitalist practices but also critically examines the potential consequences of certain social movements, including certain strands of feminism.

 


[1] https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-news/nearly-30-gen-z-adults-identify-lgbtq-national-survey-finds-rcna135510

[2] https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-transyouth-data/

[3] https://www.nbcnews.com/health/kids-health/puberty-starting-earlier-treatment-children-rcna125441

 

 

(The views expressed in this article are author’s own and do not necessarily reflect those of Khamenei.ir.)

Comment